I’ve tested a ton of buttercream recipes in my day, but my go-to is a super simple American buttercream recipe that I’ve tweaked to my liking. I’ve used this recipe for frosting countless cakes and cupcakes and I’m a big believer that a good vanilla buttercream is something every baker should have in their recipe box. There’s nothing fancy about the way this recipe is made, but it will certainly taste like you whipped up something special!
My Favorite Buttercream Frosting for Cake Decorating
This vanilla buttercream recipe is technically an American buttercream, which basically means it has a butter base and is stabilized and sweetened with powdered sugar. Most American buttercream recipes use a ton of powdered sugar to give structure to the frosting, but I have tailored this recipe to use less powdered sugar and be less sweet than your average American buttercream. As a result, the vanilla flavor really shines through and it’s the perfect consistency for cake decorating, topping cupcakes, and even creating intricate designs. It also firms up in the refrigerator, making it ideal to use as a base under fondant!
Vanilla Buttercream Key Ingredients & Substitutions
There are just a handful of ingredients you’ll need for this recipe and it’s simple to whip up for people of all skill levels. I’ll explain what role each ingredient plays in the buttercream and any substitutes you can use:
- Unsalted Butter. This is the base of the buttercream and gives the frosting a rich buttery flavor and velvety smooth texture. If you only have salted butter on hand, you can use that instead and omit the salt at the end of the recipe. And if you want a vegan version of this buttercream, you can follow this recipe which uses vegan butter sticks.
- Powdered Sugar. This adds stability to the frosting while sweetening. I like to use less powdered sugar than the average American buttercream so that the frosting doesn’t end up cloyingly sweet, but if you’d like it even less sweet you can reduce the powdered sugar amount by up to ½ Cup. Just keep in mind that the consistency of the buttercream will be thinner.
- Pure Vanilla Extract. This flavors the buttercream, and making sure you use a good quality vanilla extract or paste is one of the secrets to success. You can use any kind of vanilla extract or paste, but my favorite brands are Trader Joe’s Bourbon Vanilla and Costco Pure Vanilla Extract (the price is unbeatable). You can also substitute this ingredient for other extract flavors, just be careful how much you use because some extracts are more potent than others! If you’re looking for more flavor options, I have all of my frosting recipes here.
- Whole Milk or Heavy Whipping Cream. This thins out the buttercream while binding all the ingredients together. I like to use a liquid with lots of fat for this part because it makes the final frosting more velvety smooth, so whole milk or heavy whipping cream are my go-to’s. If you’d rather use a dairy-free option you can substitute this with any milk alternative, but keep in mind that the flavor of the liquid will affect the overall frosting flavor.
- Salt. A pinch of salt helps balance the sweetness beautifully.
Vanilla Buttercream Tips for Success
This buttercream is simple for anyone to make, but there are a few things to keep in mind when making, storing, and working with it.
- Room Temperature Ingredients. Be sure to use room temperature ingredients. This is important for ingredients to combine and create a smooth consistency. Over the years I’ve found that cutting corners like adding cold milk will create a curdled look in the final frosting because the temperature hinders the ingredients from coming together smoothly. Not the best look! So, take your ingredients like butter and milk out of the refrigerator for about an hour prior to making the frosting.
- Use the Paddle Attachment on Your Stand Mixer. Also known as the flat beater attachment, the paddle attachment is designed to incorporate just the right amount of air into the buttercream. This makes it easier to make smooth buttercream without a ton of air bubbles.
- Whip the Butter for a Long Time. To achieve the smoothest buttercream that’s also nearly white in color, you’ll want to whip the butter for a long time – about 7 minutes. In this amount of time, the butter should go from yellow to almost white and be extra smooth.
- Then Mix Everything Else on Low Speed. After you whip the butter, it’s important to keep the mixer on low speed any time you’re mixing in the additional ingredients. Even though it will take longer to mix the ingredients, keeping the mixer on low speed helps prevent air bubbles from forming in the buttercream.
- Let the Ingredients Fully Combine. After I mix in the final ingredient (salt) I like to run the mixer on low speed for another minute or two to allow everything to combine fully. This gives the powdered sugar time to dissolve as well, so the buttercream will taste smooth and not grainy.
Here’s a quick video I whipped up to show you my method for making this buttercream recipe and all my tips for success:
I’ve got more recipe videos like this one + some fun cake decorating tutorials on my YouTube channel if you want to see some more! I’m always rolling out new videos, so click the subscribe button while you’re there to ensure you never miss a new one.
Vanilla Buttercream
Ingredients
- 1 cup (226g) unsalted butter, room temperature
- 3 1/2 cups (420g) powdered sugar, sifted
- 2 tsp vanilla extract
- 2 Tbsp whole milk or heavy whipping cream, room temperature
- 1/4 tsp salt, or to taste
Instructions
- With a hand mixer or paddle attachment on your stand mixer, cream the butter on medium-high until it’s creamy and light (almost white) in color. About 7 minutes.
- With the mixer on low, add the sifted powdered sugar one cup at a time, scraping down after each addition and making sure each cup is fully incorporated before adding the next one.
- Add vanilla, milk, and salt and mix on low for another minute until fully incorporated.
Notes
- Frost 12-15 cupcakes with a piping bag
- Fill and crumb coat a three-layer 6-inch cake or two-layer 8-inch cake. To have enough for frosting and decorating as well, double the recipe.
Tips for the best buttercream consistency
There are three types of consistency for buttercream that you need to know, and each one plays a different role in cake decorating.
Medium Consistency
This is the most versatile of all consistencies. It works perfectly as a filling between layers, crumb coating, frosting a cake (especially if you want a smooth buttercream finish), and even decorating cupcakes with simple piping tips. This buttercream recipe is medium consistency as-is, so it’s super easy to spread smoothly onto cakes. To test and make sure you’ve got a medium consistency going, you should be able to dip your rubber spatula into the buttercream and it will come out with soft peaks and spread easily when you move your finger over it.
Thin Consistency
This is the perfect consistency for painting with buttercream or writing a message on your cake. To achieve it, just add 1-2 additional teaspoons of room temperature milk to thin out the buttercream.
Stiff Consistency
If you’re piping buttercream flowers, especially ones with petals that need to stand upright, you’ll need a stiff consistency. Add an extra 1/2 cup of powdered sugar per batch of the above recipe to achieve this. When you dip your rubber spatula into the frosting, it should come out with stiff peaks, but when you pipe with it, make sure it’s not so thick that you have to put a ton of extra pressure on the bag or clog the piping tip. If you’re running into these problems, fear not! You can tone it down by adding room temperature whole milk, 1 tsp at a time, until it’s just right.
I love this buttercream recipe! I forgot to save it once and had to search all over the Internet to find it again! I have a quick question. I have 2 sheet cakes I will be frosting (9×13 pans) and I’m not sure if the base recipe would be enough to cover both. What would you recommend? Thanks!
Hi Lauren! One batch of this recipe is enough to cover the top surface of one 9×13 sheet cake. If you’re also frosting the sides or adding piped borders I would make 1.5x batches of this recipe per cake, so 3x this recipe total for two 9×13 cakes. Hope that helps!
Hello, could I use salted butter for this recipe?
Hi KB! You can use salted butter, just omit the salt at the end.
can i use stawberry jam instead of puree
Hi Ashley! To flavor this buttercream with strawberry I do recommend reduced puree or freeze-dried strawberries over strawberry jam. You can use jam, but it will make this buttercream sweeter, whereas the other options won’t add any sweetness. If using jam, I’d add 1-2 Tbsp. Hope that helps!
Can this be made a day in advance and stored?
Hi Angelina! Yes. The make ahead instructions are in the notes section of the recipe card 🙂
I think I’ve made this buttercream recipe last year and it was good. I’ll be making it in 2 days for a birthday cake. Its a 3 layer 8 inch cake.
I will be crumb coating, and filling it. As well as icing it on the outside and decorating. The 2 colour l will be using are pink and green (one half of cake is a colour and the other half the other colour and the 2 layers alternate colours). The crumb coat underneath so just around edges and top will be white.
I have decided to double recipe for white, double recipe for pink and double for green. I should have more than enough?
Hi Anita! Doubling this recipe will be the perfect amount for filling, frosting, and decorating a cake of that size with that design plan. If you don’t plan on filling the cake, you could get away with 1.5x the recipe. Hope that helps!
Hi! I tried out this recipe and it’s really great, not too sweet and buttery soft. Will definitely make again.
The only issue I had is with the amount; I followed the recipe for 3 cups, weighing out the butter and sugar by weight (226 and 420 grams respectively), but somehow ended up with about 2 cups. I’ll be making a second batch tonight so I can frost the two-layer 8 inch cake I’m making. Should have made a double batch in the first place!
Can you freeze the buttercream frosting and use later.
Hi Jenny! Yes, you can freeze this buttercream frosting for up to three months in an airtight container.
Thanks for this recipe. I made 4 batches for a 3 tier wedding cake. I used it for a crumb coat for the cake as well as the filling
I put lemon curd and raspberry jam on alternate layers on top of the buttercream. I then used white chocolate ganache on top of the crumb coat. I’ve never crumb coated or baked a wedding cake before but thanks to this recipe it turned out well. It was much easier to work with a soft buttercream because it was so cold here today. I added more cream like you said and it made it softer. Thank you for the recipe.
Love this recipe! Is my go to!
However have been caught out in the past when the g’s beside the measurements don’t update when increasing the recipe amount.
Can I frost my cake the night before and leave it on the counter? Or does it need to be refrigerated? In either case, would you recommend covered or uncovered?
Hi Noor! You can certainly store this cake on the counter after frosting. It would be ideal covered. Hope that helps!
Hi… quick question do I sift the powder sugar before I weigh it or after
Hi Kristi! Sift it after weighing 🙂
Hi!
I’ve tried every buttercream recipe and mine turn out grainy all the time. & when I add the coloring – it looks streaky and not smooth or consistent. I do live in Hawaii, it’s hot and humid in my house. Could this contribute? I’ve wasted butter and so many ingredients on bad frosting mixed. The taste is always good but the consistency is never smooth or look like how the pictures look. Any tips or reasons why this happening to me?
Hi there! Have you tried this recipe yet? If your buttercream is grainy that indicates your powdered sugar isn’t properly dissolved. And what kind of food coloring are you using (gel based? What brand?)? If you’re using this recipe I recommend sifting the powdered sugar and adding it in a little at a time on low speed. Keep mixing for 1-2 minutes at low speed after adding the last ingredient to allow time for the powdered sugar to dissolve.
Hi there, I’m loving all your recipes! As for the buttercream, does it matter if I use Heavy whipping cream or whole milk as I need for the the buttercream to form a
a thin crust after piping. Thanks in advance!
I’m so happy you’re loving my recipes, Sandy! This buttercream will form a thin crust whether you use whole milk or heavy whipping cream. The heavy whipping cream does make the frosting a little silkier though.
Hi, I am looking for a buttercream recipe to use for my boyfriend’s birthday cake in a few days. I’m not sure what size it’ll be (no idea what size our tins are), but I believe it’ll be about 8 inches in diameter and I’m making 4 layers. How many batches of this recipe would you recommend for filling and crumb coating it? Also, I’m in Australia, are there any adjustments I may need to make to this recipe in regards to measurements? Thanks!
Hi Keira! For filling and crumb coating a four layer 8-inch cake, you should only need 1.5 batches of this buttercream recipe. You might even be able to get away with a single batch. If you’re planning on decorating the cake as well, I would make at least 2 batches. As for measurements, you should be totally fine. I know that Australian Cups are slightly larger than US Cups but it shouldn’t make enough of a difference here. Enjoy!
Hi there. I am in Australia and am going to try your recipe to ice and fill a three layer 9” birthday cake. Sometimes we substitute the milk/cream for just plain water…would that still suffice with this recipe. Thanks so much.
Hi Melissa! I haven’t tried subbing the milk for water before, but if it works in similar recipes I don’t see why not! My only advice is to use room temp water. Hope that helps and let me know how it goes if you try it!
Great recipe, love the flavor and consistency was perfect for piping onto cupcakes. It was too sweet for my taste so I think next time I’ll add more salt.
Could you please tell me what number to use on the mixer for step 1 (creaming the butter on medium-high until it’s creamy and white) as well as what mixer number to use for step 2 when switching it to low while adding the sifted powder sugar please? After watching the video I noticed we have the same mixer but I can’t tell what number you used. I can’t wait to make this with my niece. Thank you!!
Hi Summer! Step 1 (medium-high) would be number 8 on the mixer, Step 2 would be the Stir setting (the lowest possible). Hope that helps!
Does this crust when dried and sitting out? Or is it still a smooth consistency. I want a smooth consistency for my cupcakes.
Hi Ashley! It is a crusting buttercream, but it stays soft underneath so is still pleasant to eat. If you want a non-crusting buttercream you’ll want to try a meringue based buttercream like Swiss meringue or Italian meringue.
Hi Whitney! I was wondering if one batch of this would be enough to frost a three- layer eight inch cake. (and just to frost the outside, I am using a different frosting for the filling, and possibly for the crumb coat as well….) Hope this makes sense! Thanks!
Hi Addie! Yes, one batch of this buttercream will be enough to frost the outside of a 3-layer 8-inch cake.
First time ever making buttercream and it’s amazing. Thank you!
Can I add food colouring to this?
Yay, Kylie! I’m so happy you love this recipe. You can absolutely add food coloring!
Hi Whitney! I wasn’t sure where to ask this question, but as I will probably be using your vanilla buttercream, this seems like the place! I just bought my first bottle of Amoretti Wild Strawberry flavor and can’t wait to try it! I know that you have used these products or similar in some of your videos but what I need to ask is how much should I use? I see that this product will give me color and flavor, just not sure how much to use. Say I make a single recipe of your vanilla buttercream. Thank you and wanted to say that I am enjoying my/your book, “Anyone Can Cake”!!
Yay, Paula! I’m so excited for you to try the Amoretti Wild Strawberry flavor! If it’s the Artisan flavor, I would omit the vanilla in this buttercream recipe and add 2-3 tsp of the Amoretti Wild Strawberry flavor. Also, so happy to hear you’re loving my book!
Thank you, Whitney!! Yes, it’s the Artisan natural flavor. I am making a single recipe of your vanilla buttercream, so about 3 cups. The man on the phone (I called for some help) said to use .3 or .5 per 10 oz. I will add 2 tsp and see what happens. Thank you.
How many cups does this recipe yield? Thanks in advance
Hi Liberty! This recipe makes 3 Cups of buttercream.
Hi, thank you for your recipes. I’m looking forward to baking/decorating the vintage heart cake. Out of curiosity, what’s your go butter brand for decorating cakes?
Hi Lucero! I go through a lot of butter (which can get spendy!) so I typically use Costco or Kroger (aka generic brands) unsalted butter.
Hi!
Every time I make American buttercream, it looks streaky and ?curdled rather than having a smooth and consistent colour. I make sure all the ingredients are room temperature (18deg Celsius?) Even if I whip it up and it comes together, shortly after it turns back to being streaky.
Please help!
Hi Gemma! What kind of food coloring are you using?
Thank you for this recipe! I followed your instructions and it turned out perfectly! I used it for frosting cupcakes
Yay, Nicole! I’m so happy it was a hit!
Hello.I have a hand mixer https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B08S3MMJ7B/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o06_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1. Its a 300W 5 speed mixer,can you please advise what speed I must be using to do this?
Hi Nalini! Just follow the times and speeds in the recipe. For high speed go all the way to 5, for low speed use it on the lowest setting. Hope that helps!
Hi I’m going to use this butter cream to “fill & frost” a semi naked cake. How much will I need to do a 4 layer 10 “ round cake?
Thank you for sharing your knowledge ❤️
Love from Calgary, AB
Hi Deb! Here’s a handy chart I whipped up for calculating how many batches of buttercream you’ll need: https://sugarandsparrow.com/how-much-buttercream-do-i-need/
Can I use half and half cream instead whole milk or heavy cream?
Hi Lisa! Yes, that should be fine!
Hi, Whitney Stable Buttercream Recipe for Hot Weather…..
kindly I would like to talk to you privately, but first of all you the best n the world. the cream is amazingly fantastic and perfectly said in hot weather it is an incredibly Stable Buttercream Recipe for Hot Weather waoo grate and it is so soft a perfect to use I thought hope it perfects exactly it stayed perfectly and wwwww. thankyou from my heart I wish to talk to you privately thank you thank you
Yay, Isabella! I’m so happy to hear that the heat stable buttercream worked so well! Thanks for letting me know it was a hit 🙂
Hello! I’m so excited to make this for my daughters birthday. I just remembered that my niece is dairy free! Would I be able to use Lactaid instead of whole milk? Will doing that effect anything?
Hi there! You can absolutely sub the milk in the recipe for any non-dairy milk and if you need to sub the butter as well, here’s the vegan version of this recipe: https://sugarandsparrow.com/vegan-vanilla-buttercream-recipe/
Hello!!
Can I double the recipe
Or should I make separate batches?
Hi Wadha! You can totally double this recipe!
Thanks for your buttercream recipe!
I’m planning to make an ice cream cake for my daughters birthday and I am wondering if buttercream flowers will work on an ice cream cake?
Hi Janelle! Buttercream flowers would look lovely on and ice cream cake and will totally work!
Hello Whitney,
my sister is getting married soon and I’m baking a wedding cake as a surprise.
During my internet research, your blog and especially your vanilla buttercream recipe convinced me.
However, I’m not so sure about the amounts. Maybe you can help me.
The size of the cake is “12”, “10”, “8” and is planned with three layers of cake each.
The cake should have a buttercream dam, crumb coat and a naked finish.
How many batches of your recipe do I need for this?
Thank you for your help.
Warm greetings from Germany.
Hi Judy! I’m so excited for you to make your sister a wedding cake! For cakes that size and the type of decorating you’re doing, I would recommend 1 batch for the 8″ cake, 1 batches for the 10″ cake, and 2 batches for the 12″ cake (4 batches total). That will give you about 12 Cups of buttercream total. Let me know if you have any more questions! I’m cheering you on!
Hello,
Can I use icing sugar mixture such as this one? I find sifting icing sugar takes too long!
https://www.woolworths.com.au/shop/productdetails/96253/csr-icing-sugar-soft-mixture
Hi Anne! I’ve never heard of icing sugar mixture before, so it would be an experiment, but it looks like it’s made for icing so it might be worth a try if you feel like experimenting. Otherwise you can skip the sifting of the powdered sugar so long as there are no large lumps in it. I rarely take the time to sift my powdered sugar anymore!
Hi Whitney. Powdered sugar is like the regular white sugar in powdered form right? And NOT the Icing sugar? I had always heard that Icing sugar is used in buttercreams
Hi Sabika! Powdered sugar is icing sugar, also known as confectioner’s sugar.
I was wondering if this recipe yields enough for crumb coat, filing, and final layer
Hi Natasha! If it’s a three layer cake I would double the recipe to have enough for filling, crumb coating, and decorating.
If i want to make a cream cheese butter cream what is your ratio? I am making carrot cupcakes?
Hi Trudie! Here’s the Cream Cheese Buttercream recipe I use: https://sugarandsparrow.com/cream-cheese-buttercream-recipe/ enjoy!
How much is needed for a 4 layer 8” cake? Crumb coat, filling, frosting and piping?
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS!!!! question… can it be left out but kept in. Cool dry place for 24-48 hours?
Yay, Nivia! I’m so happy you love this recipe 🙂 Yes – you can leave this at room temperature in an airtight container for 1-2 days, or if it’s already on a cake/cupcakes you can leave it out at room temperature for that long as well. Hope that helps!
Can buttermilk be a substitute for heavy cream/Milk?
Hi Samantha! You can technically use buttermilk as a sub, but since it has more of a bitter taste that will reflect in the resulting buttercream. If you like the taste of buttermilk, go for it!
Hi there I have made your Perfect Vanilla Cake Recipe and so far it really is perfect !!
I plan to glaze this cake, I would like to make 1 layer with jam and cream but I am not sure what to recipe to use for the cream part ???
should I use this butter cream ?? will it hold up one layer of cake and taste good?
kind regards
Laura
Yay, Laura! I’m so happy you love my vanilla cake recipe as much as I do! This buttercream would be perfect for pairing with jam and glaze. It’s definitely what I would use – I use it to fill, frost, and decorate the majority of my layer cakes!
woohoo ! Thank you for the reply, I assume the stiff consistency would be best to use ?
Whitney, You are absolutely right. This is the BEST buttercream I have ever made! Thank you so much for sharing your recipe. Now I can’t wait to try your cream cheese icing. I am so glad I discovered your website! I am in the Pacific NW as well!
Yay, Lori! I’m so happy you loved this recipe and can’t wait for you to try the cream cheese buttercream recipe. Yay for the PNW!
Making this tomorrow for a giant wedding cake! Question… have you ever replaced the vanilla extract with lemon juice in this recipe? I saw the question about lemon curd, which is a good idea… wonder if that worked?!
Hi Amanda! You could totally use lemon juice as a sub for part of the vanilla, or even better, use lemon extract! I’m not sure about lemon curd but my hunch is that it would work. It would probably tint the buttercream yellow though.
how do you make your crumb frosting?
Hi Joan! I just use whatever I’ll be frosting the cake with as the crumb coat. This buttercream recipe works wonderfully as a crumb coat!
How much Buttercream for a 6 inch cake x 3 cakes depth 3 inches to fill and coat also the same for a 8 inch cake x 3 cakes to fill and coat depth 3 inches and a 10 inch x 3 cakes depth 3 inches to fill and coat .
Kind regards
Katherine
Hi Katherine! For a triple layer 6 inch cake, 1.5x the recipe. For a triple layer 8 inch cake, 2x the recipe. For a triple layer 10 inch cake, 2.5x the recipe. So the grand total would be 6x the recipe to fill and frost those three cakes. Hope that helps!
This is my favorite recipe! I use it all the time and it always gets good reviews. I am needing to make a lemon buttercream. Can I just exchange out the vanilla for lemon extract and maybe add some lemon zest?
I tried it and it turned out great. Followed your regular recipe and substituted lemon extract for the vanilla and added the zest of one lemon. It was definitely lemon frosting with a hint of tart without being too overpowering.
Hiya I just wondered if you use clear vanilla extract or not for this? I want to make a nice white coloured butter cream (I have some whitener) thank you 🙂
Hi Amy! I don’t, but if you use clear vanilla extract it will be a bit more white. Instead, I beat the butter for about 7 minutes in the beginning of the recipe to lighten the color of the butter significantly, then the overall buttercream ends up being more white in color. If I want a bright white buttercream I add a little AmeriColor Bright White. Clear vanilla extract would be helpful if you’re going for a super white buttercream though!
Thank you so much. My son turns 7 next week and I’ve made him a cake every year for his birthday since he was born. I love decorating the cakes and coming up with fun designs but I tend to shy away from the actual baking and have always used pre-made icing. You inspired me to make my own buttercream this year and I’m so pleased I did. I have just prepared mine tonight ready to ice my sons cake later in the week, I’m so happy with it, it’s so creamy and lovely and white. I did 3 x your recipe as I’m towering 3 or 4 layers and wanted to have plenty to play with when icing the cake – so I added about 4 tsp of whitener, I noticed it went a bit stiffer after that (I assume that’s normal with the extra powder) so added another spoonful of milk, hoping that will be ok. Do you find it needs any more milk after storing in the fridge or is the whisking enough alone? Thank you again, all your advice has made my baking adventures so much easier!!
Would this work well for cake pops? I will be freezing the cake balls on sticks for 2 weeks and wondered if it would be ok with this frosting? I am super excited to try! Using the rest for a mini cake to go with the cake pops
Hi there! This recipe works wonderfully for cake pops. Enjoy!
Love your buttercream. I am making a three layer 8in birthday cake for my granddaughters birthday. How much frosting do you think I need to make to frost and decorate?
How fun, Chelly! For a cake of that size, you’ll need 1.5x the recipe to frost and decorate. If you’re using the buttercream as filling also, I would make 2.5x the recipe. Enjoy!
Hey Whitney, I love this recipe and want to use it to decorate my daughter’s wedding cake. It will be a 3 tier semi naked cake with 3 layers in each tier. The tiers will be 12, 10 and 8 inch. How much buttercream will I need to fill and do the semi naked frosting please, thank you, Ruth
That’s amazing, Ruth! Congrats on your daughter getting married and how fun that you get to make the cake! I would make 6x the recipe to have enough for filling + semi naked frosting on a cake of that size. Hope that helps!
Hi Whitney wil try ur recipe it sound
Hi could I add lemon curd to buttercream for a more lemon flavour thanks
Hi Nanette! I’ve never tried that before, but it sounds like it could work! Feel free to experiment!
Hi there! Wondering if you can make this and pipe your cupcakes the night before you need them and if they would stay out at room temp? Thanks so much!
Hi Victoria! You could absolutely pipe your cupcakes the night before and leave them at room temp overnight. I do that all the time and they stay fresh. Enjoy!
The recipe looks lovely. I’m covering a 2 layer 8” cake. I want to practice making a really smooth finish and do a crumb coat. How much should I make?
Hi Vic! You’ll just need one batch of this recipe if you’re not planning on filling the cake with it. It’ll make a little more than enough for a crumb coat and finish on a cake of that size. Enjoy!
Great easy directions to follow. Thank you for sharing. What are your thoughts on using shortening?
Yay, Stepheny! So glad you love this recipe. I actually just made this recipe with half shortening and half butter and it turned out very tasty and more heat stable. I would recommend high ratio shortening or any vegetable shortening that isn’t zero trans fat.
I’m planning to you several of your recipes and tips to make a fault line lego cake for my sons birthday. Just wondering does the cake need to be refrigerated after I buttercream it? I’m putting some fondant deco inside the fault line so am worried the fondant will bleed/have condensation if I fridge it
Hi Elaine! That sounds like such a fun cake! I usually refrigerate my cakes after frosting them to preserve everything and I’ve never had problems with fondant decorations in the refrigerator overnight as long as they’re fully set (dry). Hope that helps!
Hi Whitney, I’m wanting to fill and crumb coat a 2 layer 9” cake. What quantity do I need please. Love from Julie in Derbyshire, UK
Hi Julie! To fill and crumb coat a cake of that size you’ll just need one batch. Enjoy!
I’m wanting to make a unicorn cake with this buttercream, will a double batch of this generously cover a 2 layer cake?
Hi Abby! For a two layer cake, a double batch of this recipe will give you a generous amount for both filling and frosting the cake
I have been trying to make a REALLY good Buttercream icing (mainly recipes that have Shortening & have not had ANY luck with them. I came across yours with just ALL butter & I have got to say: I FREAKING LOVED IT!! I followed your recipe to the “T” & it was PERFECT!! As is, I was able to pipe beautiful rosettes. It held up TERRIFIC!! However, I do have a question or 2. How much of this recipe should I make to fill & frost a 3 Layered 8 inch cake? Since ratios will obviously change, should I be careful on how much salt gets used to counteract some of the sweetness? Thank you again for this recipe. This will be my Buttercream Recipe from here on out.
Yay, Marie! I am so happy to hear that you love this recipe as much as I do! To answer your questions, 1) I would make 2.5x the recipe to fill and frost a triple layer 8 inch cake and 2) You should be totally fine scaling up the salt, as that is what will counteract the sweetness, but definitely taste the buttercream to see if you need more. Enjoy!
Hi there! Will this be enough for a crumb coat and a final layer? Thanks so much!
Hi Andrea! It’s definitely enough for a crumb coat and final layer for a triple layer 6 or 8 inch cake. If you’re using it as filling as well I would double it.
This was the best buttercream frosting recipe I have ever used and I’ve been baking for 15 years! If I wanted to tweak the recipe to make it as light/whipped as possible, what would you recommend?
Yay, Claire! That’s amazing to hear. If you want to make it as light/whipped as possible, I’d recommend using heavy whipping cream for the liquid.
Hiya, recipe is wonderful! With the kosher salt does it need to be fine or will it not matter if it’s coarse? Just worried about lumps of salt in the buttercream?
Hi Tony! I use coarse kosher salt and find that it dissolves just fine in the buttercream. You could certainly use a finer salt and be good with that too!
Just wanted to say I absolutely love how you show and explain everything on your pages. I’m going to try all of these techniques. I realise that must be why I’ve been struggling frosting my cakes it’s not smooth enough
Yay, Sarah! So happy to help!
Hi there I was wondering how long this would last on a cake in an airtight container at room temperature.
Thanks
Hi Lane! This buttercream lasts for 1-2 days at room temp in an airtight container or up to two weeks in the refrigerator. When you’re ready to use it, re-whip it with your stand mixer on low for about 30 seconds to bring it back to frosting consistency. Enjoy!
Hie Whitney. Im definitely going to try this. I would like to know if I can use it under fondant and which consistency I would need to make for putting ubder fondant? Thank you. Much love from South Africa
Hi Tanaka! This recipe works beautifully under fondant and you can make it as-is!
Hello Whitney
Greetings from Ghana
We predominantly have evaporated milk. Would it work out as a substitute for whole milk?
Hi Owusuaa! I’ve never tried this recipe with evaporated milk, but I think it would work just fine!
Thanks, Love from Tanzania
does icing sugar have corn starch? here in Brazil we use different names there I always doubt, it’s for the sugar that has corn starch, right?
I didn’t realize it had cornstarch in it, but after Googling, it does! This is the brand I use: https://amzn.to/326pCSi
Hello, Whitney! I am making a smash cake for my girls’ first birthday! Since i don’t give them sugar, they are too little, do you have any recommendations for sugar substitute or just making it healthier/safer for tots? Thanks!
Hi Savannah! There really isn’t a good substitute for powdered sugar in this buttercream recipe. Instead, I would look around for a low sugar frosting alternative like this one: https://www.yummytoddlerfood.com/recipes/desserts/best-smash-cake-with-yogurt-frosting/
This is great, can I use a hand mixer and get the same results?
You sure can, Mandel! Enjoy!
Super excited to try this recipe for a birthday cake & 24 cupcakes order this weekend. Just curious how I can achieve the amount of buttercream I will need for the cake and cupcakes?
I’ll be making a 2 layer cake half chocolate half vanilla.
Hi Amy! I would triple my vanilla buttercream recipe to make enough for filling and frosting a two-layer cake + frosting 24 cupcakes 🙂 enjoy!
Powder sugar is not melted in the vanilla cream. What is wrong
Hi Aysu! If your powdered sugar hasn’t dissolved, it most likely just needs a little more time to come together. Try mixing it on low speed for a minute or two longer and feel free to add a couple more tsp of room temperature milk to give the mixture more liquid to dissolve with.
Made this last night and it was amazing!!!! Doubled the recipe and it came so perfect, with the perfect amount of sweetness!!!! Thank you all the tips!!!!
Also hellow from Portland!!!
Yay, Shabina! So happy you love this recipe!
Hi there, just wondering if you recommend a certain brand of powdered sugar for your recipes.
Hi Beth! I almost always use C&H but have had fine luck with generic store brand powdered sugar as well.
Hi Whitney,
Thanks a lot for the recipe and the tips! I’m planning ok making a 9 inch wide and 4 inch high round cake, is one recipe of buttercream enough to make a crumb coat and frost the cake?
Love from Germany,
Zoe
Hi Zoe! One batch of this buttercream will be enough for crumb coating and frosting a cake of that size. If you want to use it as a filling as well, I would double the recipe. Enjoy!
Can a frosted cake with this buttercream sit at room temperature or does it need to be refrigerated?
Hi Kathy! A frosted cake can sit at room temp for 3-4 days – the sugar in this recipe preserves the little amount of dairy in it, making it totally fine to leave out. I usually store mine in the refrigerator to preserve the details and remove it from the fridge about an hour or two before serving to bring it to room temp (cake always tastes better at room temp), but you can totally just leave it out of the fridge if you want to!
Hello. Can I use this buttercream for crumb coating.?
You certainly can, Diana!
What is the filling you use on your video for smooth buttercream? Could I use a ziplock bag as a piping bag to put frosting on cake?
Hi Kathy! This basic vanilla buttercream recipe is the one I’m using in the video for smooth buttercream. And yes – a ziplock would work fine in a pinch, but I do recommend getting actual piping bags at some point if you find yourself decorating cakes regularly.
Hi,
Will this vanilla buttercream recipie be enough to coat and crumb coat a 6inch cake?
Thank you x
Hi Sara! I would double the recipe if you plan on filling the cake with this buttercream as well as crumb coat and frost it. If you’re just crumb coating and frosting, one batch will be just fine.
Hi Whitney! Thanks so much for the recipe. I was wondering if I can substitute Swerve Confectioners for the powdered sugar and still have the same consistency. Thank you!
Hi Carolyn! I have never tried substituting the powdered sugar in this recipe, so I am not sure how it will turn out but you are certainly welcome to experiment!
Hi Whitney! I have a problem…the powdered sugar does not dissolve with the butter. The buttercream is grainy. How can I prevent this? Thanks a lot!
Hi Catalina! Usually when the buttercream is grainy it’s either because the powdered sugar needed to be sifted. If you did sift the powdered sugar, then check to see that the milk was room temperature (if it’s too cold, it won’t properly dissolve the sugar) and give it a little more time to mix at the end of the recipe so that the sugar has a chance to dissolve. Keep the mixer on low speed and mix for a minute or two and that graininess should be gone! Hope that helps!
Thank you so much!
Hey Whitney
How much would I need to crumbcoat and add extra decorations such as flowers etc to a 2 layer 8 inch cake?
Hi Fizza! I would double the recipe to have enough for crumb coating and adding floral decorations to a cake of that size.
For the crumb coat and frosting for 3 6’layers cake how much of this needed?
Hi Chathurya! For crumb coating and frosting a cake, this recipe will be enough as-is. I recommend doubling it if you’re planning on using it as a filling as well.
Hi, I made your cake for my birthday and it tasted amazing so I’m gonna make it again this time I just want to add whipped double cream and chocolate between the layers instead of buttercream so how much will I need to just frost the outside and pipe on top? Like shall I just make this much? Half it? Just let me know xx
I’m so happy to hear that, Sanah! To make enough of this frosting for frosting the outside of the cake and piping on top, I would just make this recipe as-is.
Thank you Whitney
Do you have a video/blog on storing buttercream?
Hi Corina! I don’t have a video or blog on that, but here’s what I do: I place the buttercream into an airtight tupperware container and store it in the refrigerator for up to two weeks, then when I’m ready to use it I put it out on the counter for a few hours to bring it to room temp. Then, I put it back into my stand mixer and mix on low until it’s smooth. Hope that helps!
Which do you think made the buttercream better the milk or the heavy whipping cream?
The buttercream tastes the same whether you use milk or heavy whipping cream, but the heavy whipping cream makes the frosting a little bit thicker. Hope that helps!
This is my fav buttercream recipe but was wondering do you think you could you add melted white chocolate to this?
Hi Becki! So happy you love this buttercream recipe. I already have a white chocolate buttercream recipe on my blog here: https://sugarandsparrow.com/white-chocolate-buttercream-recipe/ that is what I recommend if you want to make a white chocolate flavored buttercream. Enjoy!
Hi As daft as it sounds I wondered if this would change the way the buttercream comes out if only mixing by hand. Or would you suggest to use an electric mixer? Thank you
Hi Kim! I definitely recommend mixing with an electric mixer just because it would be near impossible to whip the butter without an electric mixer of some sort (hand mixer or stand mixer).
Thank you so much, i’ve learned a looot with your blog
Lots of love from Brazil!
Yay, Amanda!! That makes me so happy!!
Hi Whitney is me, I’m making your buttercream aswell because I’m gonna be using this to ice the cake in which you know is 6 inch and 3 layers so how much do I need like do I double this recipe to frost and pipe on 3 6inch cake layers or is this enough? Thnx
I would double the recipe to fill, frost, and pipe additional details on a cake of that size 🙂
Hi!
I was wondering if I could substitute fresh table cream (18%) instead of whole milk or whipping cream and if so how much would I use? Thank you and I love your YouTube videos! So informative!
Antonietta:)
Hi Antonietta! Thanks so much for the kind words! I’ve never tried that before but I’m sure it would work just fine to sub in an equal amount for the whole milk in this recipe.
Hi Whitney! I am making a 4 tier cake that will be covered in fondant. Would this recipe work for filling the layers and frosting under the fondant? And if yes, which version should I use, thin, medium or thick?
Hi Tammy! This recipe will work for filling and frosting under fondant. I would just use the recipe as-is, no need to alter the consistency. Make sure the frosted cake is nice and chilled before adding the fondant on top! Hope that helps!
Hi…I’m making a taller(5 – 1 inch layers) 6 inch round cake….so I’m guessing will I need 3x the recipe? Or 4? Should I use the basic recipe consistency to fill between the layers, then add extra milk for the thinner consistency you mention for the outside?
Thank you
Hi Jane! For a tall 6 inch round cake I would use 2.5x the recipe. That should be more than enough to fill and frost the cake. The recipe works for filling and frosting as-is, no need to alter the consistency!
I can’t have lactose especially can’t have any thing with whole milk or heavy cream or anything I can have foods wit small amounts of like skim milk but sumtimes get sick from that but what can I do to make it still?
Hi Athena! You can make this dairy free by substituting an equal amount of vegan butter for unsalted butter and an equal amount of dairy-free milk of your choice (I love coconut milk with this recipe). Enjoy!
Hi Whitney,
I followed your smash cake recipe for my niece’s smash cake. My sister asked for an exposed/rustic cake look so I would only need to fill and crumb coat the 3 layer 4″ cakes. Do you think I would have enough buttercream if I halved this recipe?
Thank you!
Hi Stacey! You would totally have enough to fill and frost this cake with a semi-naked finish if you half the recipe.
Hi Whitney,
I am excited to give this icing recipe a go. I am wanting to pipe some stars and rosettes as decoration on to a cake. Once I have filled the cake layers, made a crumb coat and re-iced the cake with the recipe above should I add additional powder sugar to the remaining icing to make it a medium consistency for piping? Do you typically make two different icing batches? One for filling and decorating the cake and another batch for decorating?
Thank you for the tips!
Hi Lauren! I usually do add just a little bit more powdered sugar to the remaining buttercream for decorative piping, but only if the buttercream seems too thin to hold it’s shape when piped. I make one big batch of buttercream for everything and just add additional powdered sugar (literally just mix a little bit in at a time) as needed when I get to the piping part. Hope that helps!
I LOVE this recipe, i tried it out for the first time recently as i have been making buttercream for some time now but i wanted to see if i could make it better, more creamier and less sweet. And this recipe was just that! Best recipe i have found. I have been researching for a long time now, and found it difficult to find a british buttercream recipe i liked, as i’m from london. But i didn’t like them, then a lot of american recipes are just too sweet or have too many ingredients for my liking. After making this and alternating it a little, i used salted butter because i saw another recipe discussing the myth of unsalted butter etc and i’ve always used salted for baking but when using it in buttercream i think it just ruins it for me, so salted butter definitely helped! Also instead of just sifting the icing sugar (powdered sugar) once i did it twice, i never used to sift my buttercream and it sometimes would be grainy also i decided to purchase a better quality icing sugar i think that’s what helped. And i had never thought about adding double cream as usually i’ve seen just milk but these new tips and ingredients really became a game changer. It was so creamy, light, fluffy and the perfect amount of sweetness. I never usually comment but i just had to as i was going to be using it again. So thank you!
I’m so happy to hear you love this recipe, Iqra! I’ll have to try salted butter sometime and see how it tastes!
What happens if use salted butter instead of salted? Will it be too salty? Or should I use salted butter and spent add any salt?
Hi Sara! It will definitely be more salty if you use salted butter, so be sure to omit adding salt at the end if you do so and it should taste fine!
Hi Whitney, I use a very similar ABC recipe and I love it! I always use the whisk attachment and have just recently seen people use the paddle attachment to mix their buttercream instead. What are the pros and cons of using either attachment? Thanks in advance!
Hi there! I’ve never used a whisk attachment for this recipe, and only because I’ve heard it adds extra air into the buttercream. I’m not sure how it actually compares since I’ve always used a paddle attachment, But I also know bakers who swear by the whisk! That’s probably not super helpful but until I do a side by side comparison I won’t know the pros and cons 🙂
Thank you so much this recipe is a winner indeed.
I am grateful for the explanation on the consistency of the buttercream
Greetings from Namibia
Yay, Rachael! It makes me so happy to hear that the recipe was a hit and the blog post was helpful. Thanks for taking the time to let me know and love from Portland!
Hi Whitney, curious if this would be enough for a three layer cake each of an inch
Hi Rahemeen, for a triple layer cake I would double the recipe. Hope that helps!
Hi Whitney!
This was so helpful! Are those burgundy roses? May I ask what gel colouring you used to get them so dark. TIA. Love from Seattle ❤️
Hi Sarh! I used Americolor Burgundy color gel for those and only colored a little bit of buttercream, so I didn’t have to use a whole lot to get that dark color: https://amzn.to/32osiLT
I’m planning on making your sprinkle fault line cake, you wrote there that you need 1.5 batches of buttercream. How many batches total would I need for the entire cake filling, frosting, and the fault line? (I’m making a 3 layer 6 inch cake.) Also can I use thin consistency buttercream for filling my cake or will it spill out the sides? Will my frosting stay good if it’s covered in a bowl in the refrigerator?
Thanks for your recipe!!
Hi there! Two batches of buttercream will be the perfect amount for filling, crumb coating, and replicating this fault line design. The frosting will keep in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two weeks, just bring it back to room temperature and rewhip it with your stand mixer before using it on your cake. And as far as consistency goes, I would use the recipe as-is for filling and frosting the cake. That’s the consistency I use all the time. Hope that helps!!
So would that mean that half a batch is enough to crumb coat a 3 layer 6 inch cake? (Because I noticed that you wrote by the fault line cake that you need 1.5 batches in addition to a crumb coated cake)
I just made this with the vegan variation (using the Earth Balance -78% vegetable oil spread- vegan buttery sticks and room temp soy milk). It came out slightly grainy and I think I may run into the same issue when I made buttercream another time. I haven’t frosted the cake but the frosting doesn’t seem to be the right texture. It seems to almost be a bit grainy…??
Hey! Love your website!! I’m trying to make a birthday cake, and this has been so helpful!! I do have a few questions. If I use clear vanilla extract, will this make the buttercream white instead of yellow? Also, can the buttercream be tinted pink(doing two tiers)?
I saw the comment about storing the cake in the refrigerator after it’s frosted, but I’m planning to add a few fondant decorations. I’ve read fondant should not be refrigerated. Any suggestions on this?? Should I wait to add the fondant decorations until it’s reached room temperature again? Or just avoid refrigerating it? I was planning to frost the day before.. Thanks in advance!!
Hi Connie! To answer your questions: 1) This buttercream is already pretty white as-is from whipping the butter for so long, but using clear vanilla extract will make the buttercream even more white. 2) it can be tinted pink with the food color gel of your choice 3) I have stored cakes with fondant decorations in the refrigerator overnight before and they ended up being totally fine, but I know some bakers in more humid states have problems with that. I always refrigerate my cakes after decorating to preserve the details, so that’s what I recommend. Hope that helps!
Hi maam, great buttercream recipe! Everyone in my family loved it. All the credit goes to you. That smile on my brothers face was so adorable. I have seen all your vlogs and they are quite interesting. lots of love from me and my family.
Yay, Shriya! So happy the recipe was a hit. Thanks for taking the time to let me know, that totally makes my day!
Hi,
You butter cream looks great but won’t it be too sweet after adding double amount of sugar?
Hi Noopur, I’m not sure what you mean by “double the amount of sugar”. This recipe is meant to have the amount of sugar and other ingredients specified, and I’ve purposefully made it less sweet than other American buttercream recipes by lessening the sugar and adding salt in for balance.
Hey!
I was wondering, how does your icing turn out so pale white? Whenever I make buttercream, it turns out quite yellow because the butter is yellow. Do you have to add something, or do you use a special kind of butter? I’ve experimented with adding a tiny amount of purple food colouring, but its just turned it grey!
Thank you. X
Hi Ruth! I whip the butter for 7-10 minutes before adding the other ingredients in this recipe, until the butter is almost white in color. That sets the recipe up to turn out pretty white as-is, but if you want it extra bright you can add an icing whitener like Americolor Bright White: https://amzn.to/2EAQXnm
Can this recipe cover and fill a 3 layer 9 inch cake if I double it?
Hi Sally! If you’re filling and frosting a triple layer 9-inch cake, I would make 2.5x this recipe.
Can this recipe cover a 3 layer 9 inch cake if I double it?
Hi Sara! If you’re just covering the cake (filling and stacking with other frostings/fillings), 1.5x this recipe will be the perfect amount.
Hi Whitney I have a question about the speed medium high to start with butter, which number on your KA?, because I have KA too. Thanks! from Spain
Hi Teresa! I whip the butter on speed 8. Hope that helps!
Hello
How many batches do I need to fill and coat a cake ? 6 inch 3 layers
Thank you !
Hi Randa! I always double this recipe for filling and frosting a triple layer 6 inch cake.
This icing was delicious! Do you have a post or tutorial on coloring the icing? I had a terrible time getting the right colors for a cake but there aren’t many tutorials out there that I found. Everything I’ve seen says to not add much gel coloring except my toddler’s rainbow cake (with dark/bold-ish pastel colors) ended up looking like a Easter/gender reveal cake because I couldn’t get the colors right in the correct quantities to pipe multicolored designs. I didn’t want true bold colors, but wasted so much time and icing trying to get it just right. What’s the trick?
Hi Julie! So happy to hear that you love this recipe! I am currently working on a tutorial on how to color buttercream as part of my Cake Basics series, so stay tuned. I’ll make an announcement about it on my Instagram when it’s ready!
Hi!
I was wondering how much frosting you typically use between your layers, to crumb coat, to frost, & decorate? I am trying to get my measurements down to a science so I make just enough of what I need. Thank you!
Hi Kacie! It totally depends on the size of the cake. If it’s a 3-layer 4 inch round cake, one batch of this recipe is enough to fill, frost, and decorate. If it’s a triple layer 6-inch or 8-inch cake, a double batch of this recipe is perfect. Hope that helps!
Hi Whitney! I just started making cakes a few months ago and I’m obsessed with making flowers. I just haven’t found the right consistency to withstand the crazy humidity here in Austin, Texas! Not sure where you are located but what’s your experience with these flowers staying in place in humid weather? I read somewhere to add shortening and I actually tried that with one of the buttercream recipes and it was absolutely disgusting! I really want to find a good buttercream to hold. What are your thoughts?
Hi Tisha! I’m in the pacific northwest, so it’s not quite as humid/hot over here. Substituting half (or all) of the butter in this recipe with vegetable shortening (the higher the fat ratio the better!) is the only way I know to stabilize it for heat and humidity! I wish I had another suggestion for you but the science behind it is that butter just starts to soften and melt above 75ish degrees and shortening is just much more heat tolerant.
Darn. That’s kind of what I thought you would say! 🙂 Most of my research comes up with the same answer. Although, a few recipes suggested cornstarch. I guess I need to start making two separate buttercream recipes, one to frost the cake and the other (with shortening) for flowers. Most people I know don’t really eat all the decor… I’ll keep playing with it. Thanks for the input though!
Hi! This buttercream recipe looks amazing! I am making a 4 tier wedding cake (12″, 10″, 8″ and 6″ double tiers). How many batches of this frosting will I need? Also, if I use salted butter should I leave out the salt called for in the recipe?
Thanks!
Hi Kristi! Wow, that’s a big cake! Maybe start with 5x this amount and go from there? It’s hard to say for sure because I don’t know how you’ll be decorating the cake (semi-naked finish? accent piping? etc). To give you an idea of how much this makes, I usually double this recipe to fill and frost one triple-layer 8 inch cake. And yes, if you use salted butter go ahead and omit the salt at the end.
Do you need to use different consistencies buttercream for filling vs crumb coating and frosting the cake? Would you do a thick consistency for filling the cake ?
Hi Saba! I always just use this recipe as-is for filling, frosting, and crumb coating my cakes. The only time I thicken the consistency is if I’m filling a cake with a softer filling and need to create a strong buttercream dam around the edge. Here’s a video that shows what I mean: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jwvyChljIQ4&t=2s
Hi!
I would like to make this into a lemon buttercream. How would you recommend doing that? I know that adding only the extract can sometimes result in a bitter taste because there is no acidity, but I don’t want to add too much liquid with the juice. Thanks!
Hi Ellen! To turn this into lemon buttercream, omit the vanilla and instead add the zest and juice of a small lemon (about 3-4 Tbsp of lemon juice). I would also half the amount of whole milk to cut down on the liquid. I do have a lemon buttercream recipe here but it makes a bit more than this vanilla buttercream recipe does (enough to frost a triple layer 6-inch cake): https://sugarandsparrow.com/strawberry-lemonade-cake-recipe/
Could this recipe be made with a hand mixer?
Hi Jamie! It can. Just follow the same speeds and mixing times and you should be good to go with a hand mixer!
Hi Whitney! Can I ise vanilla bean paste instead of vanilla extract for this recipe?
Love all your helpful posts by the way ♥️
Hi Anisha! You totally can sub vanilla bean paste. So tasty!
Why is my buttercream grainy? No matter what I do my sugar never melts into the butter
Hi Manisha! It’s hard to know exactly what’s causing the graininess since I am not able to observe your exact method/ingredients used with this recipe. After searching Google a bit, it seems like grainy texture can happen from the following reasons: 1) ingredients aren’t room temperature (usually when they’re too cold), 2) powdered sugar is made from a less-dissolvable source (apparently Cane Sugar is the best source to use), 3) powdered sugar was not sifted, and 4) you didn’t give the mixture enough time to come together at the end. If your ingredients are room temp, you’re using the right powdered sugar, and you’ve sifted it, try mixing it on low for an additional minute or two to give it more time to dissolve. If it’s still grainy, try add a tsp of room temperature milk and continue mixing.
I have the same issue. My buttercream icing is always grainy. I followed all above 4 points you mentioned but it’s still grainy 🙁
Hi Nikki! If it’s still grainy after all four of those suggestions and you haven’t made any substitutions and made sure your ingredients were all room temp, my only recommendation to fix it is to add 1-2 tsp more (room temp) liquid and mix it on low with your stand mixer for 1-2 more minutes. The mixing on low should allow the sugar the time it needs to dissolve.
So I’m doing your smash cake recipe and I also wanted to use this buttercream but it yields a lot of such a small cake. How much do you think I should divide it
Hi Jada! I typically use one batch of this to fill, frost, and decorate a smash cake. If you half the recipe it will be just enough to fill and frost with a thin layer of frosting.
Excellent, I already made the recipe and for my best of all you are the maximum thousand thanks
So happy you love this recipe, Yudirma! Thanks for taking the time to let me know 🙂
Hi! Your vanilla cupcake recipie with your vanilla buttercream recipie is delicous!
Thank you so much, Ale! So happy to hear you love those recipes!
Hi your frosting recipie is AMAZING I have been using it ever since the first day I made it!
Hi!
How much should I double this to have enough frosting to fill & frost a three layer 9” cake? Thank you!
Hi Kacie! Doubling this recipe should be just enough for filling and frosting a three layer 9 inch cake. If you want to do any additional decorating with the frosting (piping, etc) then I recommend making 2.5x the recipe.
Thanks for this recipe. I know it’ll affect it taste-wise, but will using margarine affect this recipe texture-wise?
Hi there! I’m not exactly sure how it will affect the texture to use margarine instead of butter, as I’ve never tried it before. But after a quick Google search it looks like margarine is a suitable substitute for butter in a buttercream recipe! I’d say go for it!
Hi! I have made your recipe before and I had to keep myself from eating it all before I had my cake frosted! I am making a “number 3” cake for my twins’ birthday this weekend using 2 Bundt cakes. I will do a crumb coat and then pipe stars all over it. How many batches would you recommend making? I will be making a few different colors with it so I don’t want to come up short and then have to try to match the colors if I have to make another batch.
Hi Sarah! So happy you love this recipe and your cake sounds so cute!! To be on the safe side, I would double this recipe to ensure you have enough for crumb coating and decorating. You might end up with a little extra, but in my opinion it’s better to have a little more than barely enough 🙂 have fun!
Hi from Australia Whitney! Thanks for all the detailed info. I’m about to try your galaxy cake next week for my 5 year old. I was wondering, do you sugar syrup your cakes before layering/frosting/crumb coating them? Or does that depend in the cake recipe used?
Love your videos, Belinda
Hi Belinda! I don’t typically syrup my cakes before filling and frosting, as they’re already pretty moist and flavorful as-is. It’s something you can totally do with any layer cake though!
I love this buttercream recipe! I hate it when buttercream is too sweet and this one is perfect.
How much of this recipe would I need to fill and frost a 3 or 4 (I haven’t decided yet!) layer 8-inch cake? Would I double the recipe? x
So happy you love this recipe, Elissa! I would make 2.5x the recipe to fill and frost a 3-4 layer 8-inch cake.
I have being searching for a good butter cream recipe, God bless you for this knowledge. I will definitely give it a try.
Excited for you to try this recipe, Precious!
Hi! I love this recipe! I have been searching for one that wasn’t quite so sweet, and this is perfect!! I was wondering if there is a brand of vanilla you love? Right now I use Molina. Thanks again for sharing your delicious recipe!
Hi Aubree! So happy you love this recipe as much as I do! I love using Trader Joe’s Bourbon Vanilla Extract in mine.
Hi, thank you for sharing. If using milk or cream , how safe is it to be left out of fridge? Some cakes will be out on table etc at parties. Thank you
Hi Sue! The sugar content in the frosting actually preserves the small amount of dairy in this recipe, so it’s safe to leave out on a frosted cake for up to 3-4 days.
Hello! I can’t wait to try this recipe! Have you ever added chocolate to this, either melted chocolate or cocoa powder, and if so, how much? I am always looking for a good chocolate American buttercream recipe to go with classic yellow cake.
Thanks!
Hi Bethany! I do have the chocolate version here and it pairs perfectly with yellow cake: https://sugarandsparrow.com/chocolate-buttercream-recipe/ one of my favorite cake flavor combos of all! If you need a good yellow cake recipe, I have one as well: https://sugarandsparrow.com/yellow-cake-recipe/
Hello there! To avoid too many air bubbles in your bc, do you add the sugar at low speed? There seems to be different techniques out there! Th am you!
Hi Andree, I do add the sugar at a low speed and I find that it helps control the amount of air being incorporated into the buttercream. I’ll add that to the instructions!
Thank you for sharing with us ! If I want to colour this buttercream when do I put the food coloring ? An if I want to taste it for example with Nutella !? Can I do it ? Love from Greece
Hi Efi! If you want to color this buttercream, first make the buttercream, then add the food color gel to it afterwards. You can certainly add Nutella or any other flavorings, but the amounts are going to vary. I do have a recipe for Nutella buttercream here: https://sugarandsparrow.com/pretzel-nutella-cake-recipe/
Hi Whitney! I am baking a cake next week that is 3 layers and 6 inches round. How much of this recipe should I use?
Hi Sophie! I always double this recipe for a three layer 6 inch cake.
I finally succeeded a buttercream perfectly thanks to this recipe. Thank you so much for such a great recipe and instructions. My cake has been stacked and crumb coated with my first batch and I cant wait to make my second batch and using it to make a camo cake.
So happy you love this recipe, Samanatha! That totally makes my day. Thanks for letting me know and good luck on your camo cake!
Does this method work with Swiss or Italian buttercream as well so long as the consistency is correct or does it require the crusting that simple buttercream has?
Hi Amanda. Depends on which method you’re talking about. If it’s filling and frosting a cake, Swiss and Italian buttercreams work just fine. I’m not sure about creating buttercream flowers with either of those buttercreams though. The American buttercream crusts and dries firm, making it easy to work with buttercream flowers. Not sure if Swiss or Italian would do the same.
Hi Whitney! I just finished making this frosting. One quick question… if I’m on a low carb diet can I eat the entire bowl and not worry about my diet? Bahaha!! Just kidding. I crack myself up! It’s a great, easy recipe, love it!
Haha! I’m so happy you love this recipe, Lori!
Hi Whitney!
I’m looking to use this recipe to make some buttercream for a birthday cake, and I was wondering what brand/kind of butter you use? I’ve been doing a lot of research and I’ve heard a lot about European butter & high fat butter. Do you recommend this for this recipe? Is there a specific kind of butter you think is best for this specific recipe?
Hi Abby! I have never tried European/high fat butter before, I always just get mine at Costco (It’s classified as American butter). After doing a little research on European butter, I’m sure it will work just fine in this recipe if you want to use it. I’ve read that it has a tangier taste (which should be counteracted fine with the sugar in this recipe) and yellower hue, so you might end up with a yellower buttercream as a result. Just some things to consider. Let me know if you try it, I’m curious now!
Very well described. Thank you ! What do you suggest if we live in a cold county and the butter has to sit overnight on the counter to come to room temperature? I don’t use microwave. So what’s the best method ?
Thank you in advance.
Hi there! You only really need about 1-2 hours for butter to come to room temp (which should be about 65 degrees), but leaving it out overnight is fine. You can also cut the butter into smaller pieces and it will reach room temp even quicker.
Another question, is it true that colors set better when you add white food coloring and then the color that you want the cake to be ? Been wanting to know this for a while. Thank
You!!!
Adding whitener will just give you a pure white base (as opposed to yellow or off white), so when you add the food color gels, the color ends up being more pure. This buttercream ends up being pretty white as-is (from whipping the butter for so long), so I’ve never had to really add additional whitener to achieve rich colors with it.
First of all, I love you! I have a question, is this buttercream ok to put your white chocolate ganache on?(drip cake) and another question, can I add concentrated oil flavor to the buttercream, for example, strawberry oil flavor? Should
I still add the vanilla extract? Thanks !
Hi Alejandra! You can definitely do a white chocolate ganache drip cake over this buttercream (I do all the time!). Just make sure the buttercream cake is chilled before dripping with the room temp ganache. I’ve never added concentrated oil to buttercream, but if they’re made for flavoring I would add just a little bit at a time until you get the desired taste. I would still add the vanilla extract if it’s a complimentary flavor to the one you want to add.
Hi, I was just wondering how much buttercream I would need to make for a semi-naked cake with four layers?
Thank you so much!!
Hi there! For a 6 or 8 inch four-layer cake, I would make 1.5 batches of this vanilla buttercream recipe. That will be enough to fill the layers and frost them in a semi-naked finish.
Hello Whitney,
Thank you so much for sharing all of your talents.
I tried your medium consistency vanilla buttercream to frost cupcakes. However, I am so slow at frosting that by the time I finish frosting five cupcakes, my hands have heated up the rest of the frosting in the piping bag making the frosting very melty and aesthetically unpleasing. So, I tried adding less to the bag, refrigerated it, whipped it up, and then frosted but then I get these bad ruffley edges for the rosettes. PLEASE HELP. I can’t seem to get the temperature right to frost.
Hi Sam, I have a few tricks for that because it’s happened to me before! Prepare one piping bag by fitting it with the piping tip. Then, fill a second piping bag with the frosting, snip off the end, and place it inside the piping bag with the piping tip. This will help prevent the frosting inside from heating up too quickly. Also, try running your hands under cold water and drying them off before piping. This will slow down the process of your hands getting too hot. Between those two things, I think you can buy yourself lots of extra time for piping those cupcakes!
Hi Whitney! Can i use 1/2 cup margarine and 1/2 cup shortening?
Hi Roneth! I’ve never tried this recipe with margarine, but I have tried it with half butter and half shortening (which works great!). I’d say give it a try, but I can’t recommend it confidently since I don’t know how it will turn out with margarine.
I’ve used stick margarine instead of unsalted butter. DO NOT used Country Crock or any whipped margarine. It’s always better with real butter. I generally use half butter and half Crisco because it’s more stable. For decorating I sub all Crisco.
How much buttercream you use for a cake? To decorate it
Hi Alia! It depends on the size of the cake. For a three-layer 6 inch cake (the most common size I make), I double this vanilla buttercream recipe.
Do you have a butter brand preference?
Hi Daniela! I don’t really have a butter preference, I just buy unsalted butter in bulk from Costco (their brand).
Interesting! I have not bought the Costco butter because it says sweet cream and I thought that was different. Did you use Costco butter for your vanilla cake too?
Hi, could you explain what Tbsp mean? I cant find it in the dictionary 🙂
Hi Kasia! Tbsp = tablespoon.
Hey I live in a area which is quite humid so is there anyway to prevent my buttercream melting without using shortening
Hi Rhea! Substituting butter with shortening is the only method I’ve tried for stabilizing the buttercream for hot/humid environments. If you’d rather go the all-butter route, you can always keep the cake in the fridge until about 30 minutes before you serve it. That keeps it nice and firm for presentation.
Hello! I am a home baker and for some reason my previous recipe (which uses shortening) has just been, well, falling short lately! So I plan on trying out yours this weekend!
Quick question regarding coloring – most of my cakes are not white and so how I do it now is incorporate the color into the cream/vanilla and then put it in the butter/sugar mix. Would you recommend doing this or what is your “go to” method for adding color!
I’m so excited to find your site, I love your tutorials! I am going to try out a fault line cake this weekend I think!
Hi Ashley! I’m so excited for you to try this vanilla buttercream recipe and make a fault line cake. For coloring, I usually make the batch of buttercream, then add food color gel to tint it. I find that it’s easier to control the color that way, but you do you!
Thanks for this wonderful recipe! Do you have YouTube channel? I am from Philippines
Hi Desiree! Thanks so much for your kind words. I do have a YouTube channel! It’s here: https://www.youtube.com/sugarandsparrow
I was wondering about how many cupcakes does this decorate? Wanted to use this for a cupcake cake and some extra cupcakes, 60 in total
Hi Hannah! This recipe will decorate about 20 cupcakes.
Thanks Whitney! I love your site!!
I’ve tried this recipe a couple times now and I love it!! Not overly sweet which is great. However, each time I’ve made it I get some serious air bubbles, which makes getting that nice, smooth layer of frosting on my cake difficult. Any tips??
Hi Bel! Glad you’re loving the vanilla buttercream recipe! So the only real way to eliminate air bubbles is to make sure you don’t overwhip the buttercream (more whipping time = more air being incorporated). If you do end up with air bubbles, try pressing the buttercream to the sides of your mixing bowl with a rubber spatula to release some of that air.
Sometimes when I’m frosting a cake and finding that there are air bubbles that can’t easily be smoothed out, I will get the first frosting layer as smooth as I can and then chill the cake for about 30 minutes, then fill in all the air bubble holes with more buttercream and smooth that over. It makes for a super smooth cake. Here’s a full tutorial with all my best tips on how to get the smoothest finish possible: https://sugarandsparrow.com/how-to-frost-a-cake/ Hope all that helps!
Hi Whitney,
what can you substitute vanilla extract with? I have Vanilla essence and vanilla paste but I’m not sure if I can use them to replace it? please will you let me know if I can substitute with these and in what measurements.
thanks
Hi Ashley! You can substitute vanilla extract with vanilla paste. Just use equal amounts of vanilla paste per amount of vanilla extract and you’ll be good!
Hi Whitney,
When you say you use this to frost your cakes, is that for the crumb coat also? And how much doubling will I have to do for a 10in rounds cake? I’m really excited to try this recipe since i’ve stayed away from traditional butter cream because of the sweetness.
Hi, Jackie! This recipe works for filling, crumb coating, and frosting the cake. For a 10 inch round cake, if you’re using it as filling as well as frosting, I would make 2.5x the recipe. If you’re just crumb coating and frosting the cake, I would make 1.5x the recipe. Hope you love it!! Let me know how it goes.
Thank you! I’m a basic cook, but I followed your buttercream (and chocolate dripping ganache) recipe, plus the tips. They were a great help & they both came out perfectly!
That’s so wonderful to hear, Lauren!! So happy you’re enjoying the recipes and tutorials!!
Will this amount of sugar taste very sweet?
Hi, Jessy! I don’t think this recipe is too sweet. I purposefully reduced the sugar (most other recipes call for 4+ cups of sugar) and added salt to make it sweet, but not overly so.
Hi Whitney! Do you use the thin consistency to cover the outer layer of the cake? Which consistency is best if I need to paint it in gold? Another question what happens if I want to reduce the sugar level does it affect the consistency of the buttercream?
Hi Natalie! I use thin-consistency to frost cakes (it’s the same measurements as the recipe above). If you add less sugar, the consistency will be even thinner, so I would reduce the amount of milk depending on how much you reduce the sugar (otherwise it might be too liquidy). You can eyeball that part. Thin consistency buttercream will also be perfect for painting a gold finish. You just need to refrigerate the cake after frosting it for about 30 minutes (until the buttercream is firm to the touch) before painting.
Hi Whitney, Could I make a strawberry buttercream using freeze-dried strawberries and this recipe? If so, do you have any recommendations on quantity of freeze-dried strawberry powder to butter/sugar/cream/milk? Strawberry frosting is the best, but I can’t use most recipes as they require extract and I’m allergic to red 40. Thanks!
Hi Jessica! You can totally make strawberry buttercream using freeze-dried strawberries – it’s so tasty! Just use this recipe but substitute the raspberries for strawberries: https://sugarandsparrow.com/raspberry-buttercream-recipe/
I’ve nevwr loved an ABC frosting more than this! & the smoothest I’ve ever been able to get on a cake. Thank you for the recipe!
I’m so happy to hear that, Jessica! Glad you love the recipe!
Do you have a similar recipe for chocolate buttercream frosting?
Hi, Kim! Yes, I do have a tasty chocolate buttercream recipe here: https://sugarandsparrow.com/chocolate-buttercream-recipe/
Thank you so much
All the way from Tanzania
No problem, Neelam! So happy you love the recipe 🙂 Love from Portland!
Ho There,
How long does the buttercream last? Do you think it is OK to make the buttercream in advance, store it in the fridge, and then bring it back to room temp before using? Thanks so much!
Heather
Hi Heather! I make this buttercream recipe ahead all the time. You can store it in an airtight container at room temperature for two days, then rewhip it with your stand mixer to bring it back to creamy consistency. If you’re wanting to store it for longer than two days, place it in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to two weeks. When you’re ready to use it, bring it back to room temp and rewhip with your mixer before using. Hope that helps!
I made the buttercream and it is absolutely delicious!! I’m so excited about this recipe! One more question, once the cake is frosted what is the best way to store it? Do you cover it with plastic wrap or a cake platter with lid?
Yay, Heather! So happy to hear that! Once the cake is frosted, the buttercream acts as a barrier to hold moisture within the cake, so there’s no need to cover it with additional plastic wrap, etc. I just keep it in the refrigerator until a few hours before serving.
Hola es la primera vez que entro en tu blog, y vaya me encantó. Mi pregunta es, cuánto dura la consistencia de la crema si hago una torta con picos como la de unicornio que tú hiciste, pero si la dejo al aire libre en un cumpleaños
Hola, Leonela, haría la crema de mantequilla de consistencia media y debería estar bien salir en una fiesta de cumpleaños al aire libre durante una hora o dos, siempre que la temperatura exterior sea de 75 grados o menos. Si hace más calor que eso, dejaría la torta en el refrigerador hasta una hora antes de servirla.
This was so helpful
Yay, Rika! I’m so happy to hear that!
I use crisco in my icing. Can I use the same ratio you have with the butter? Also, what about the butter crisco? Thoughts?
Hi Sunshine! I’ve never tried this recipe with Crisco or Butter Crisco, so it would be an experiment for you! I think it’s worth trying though, and if you do I would try it with the same ratio I have with butter. Let me know if you try it, I’m curious now!
Hello! I would like to know if with these quantities you decorate the whole cake or make more quantity of cream. Thank you
Hi Martina! I double the recipe if I’m filling and frosting a 6 inch cake, but as-is it will fill and frost a 4 inch cake or can be used to decorate about 18-20 cupcakes. Hope that helps!
how much powdered sugar and milk do you use to pipe cupcakes?
Hi Ashton! I just make the recipe as-is for piping cupcakes. If you feel that you need more powdered sugar to make the buttercream more stiff, you can add another 1/2 cup or so.
Your cake is gorgeous!! I have a quick question about the sifted powdered sugar. Do you measure first then sift into the creamer butter or do you sift into a measuring cup? Thanks!!
Hi Marlena! I usually sift the powdered sugar into a big bowl, then spoon it into a measuring cup and level it off before adding it to the butter. Hope that helps!
I live in middle Alabama, and all butter buttercream will melt in my kitchen, much less during transport even if it’s been refrigerated. Do you have any tips for making it more stable. Currently, I use 1/2 butter and 1/2 Crisco. I’ve just learned about SweetX, but wondered about the taste.
Hi Donna! I hear that replacing some (or all) of the butter with shortening is the best way to make it heat resistant, and using a high ratio shortening (like Sweetex) is better than using Crisco. Here’s a recipe I’ve made in the past that replaces some of the butter with shortening (with instructions in the notes on how to make it even more stable): https://www.designmeacake.com/how-to-make-crusting-buttercream
Thank you for sharing!!! And the tips are so awesome!
Hi. After frosting the cake, should I refrigerate it or is it okay to keep it in room temperature?
Hi Debbie! While you can technically leave the frosted cake at room temperature for up to two days, I usually refrigerate it until about an hour before serving the cake. I only do that to ensure the frosting stays picture perfect + the cake is easier to handle for a delivery if it’s cold. Just make sure you serve the cake at room temperature because it tastes better that way!
Hi
Just love your blog. I’m new to frosting and decorating cakes, your blog explains it very well. Loved your spatula painting decor idea. I’m definitely going to try it out. Thanks and love from India .
Swetha, that makes my day! So happy you’ve found my blog helpful and I’m cheering you on in your newfound love for cake decorating!
I plan on making this cake for my 40th this weekend. I’m doing a 4 layer 8inch round cake. How many quantities of buttercream would I need?
And is it whiter than a Swiss buttercream? Mine always tend to look so yellow
Thanks
Hi Amber! Happy birthday! For a 4 layer 8 inch cake, you’ll need 2.5x this recipe if you’re planning on using it as a filling and a frosting. Just multiply each ingredient by 2.5 to get the correct amount. And yes – this buttercream should be much whiter than a swiss meringue as long as you whip the butter in the beginning for the full time specified. Enjoy!
Thanks alot…I’m newbe from Indonesia
Hi Ayou! Hope you love the buttercream recipe!
Wow!!! Ur recipes are sooo wonderful and amazing. I just love them. It’s soooo simple and easy to understand. Thnks a lot for sharing ur wonderful recipes with everyone
Thanks so much Zumaira! That’s so kind!
Thanks for sharing, looking forward to using this
Thank from Russia ))
Of course, Tamara! Love from Portland!
Hi Whitney, Thanks so much for your awesome tips! Can I ice my cake to completion then keep it in the fridge for about 3 days? Do I need a cake box if so?
Thank you x
Hi Katie! That should work, but I wouldn’t frost it any farther in advance just to make sure it stays fresh for serving. A cake box would help prevent it from absorbing other fridge flavors. Here’s a blog post I wrote on making cakes ahead just in case: https://sugarandsparrow.com/making-cakes-ahead/
Thank you Whitney! I am new to your blog amd I adore it already! You’re posts are to the point, and funny and your recipes aren’t overwhelmingly or complicated! From this busy F/t Mommy, big thanks!
Blessings to you!
Aw thanks so much Elizabeth! That is so kind and I’m happy you’ve found my recipes and blog posts useful!
Could I use Margarine instead of the Butter for this recipe or will it have an effect on the colour or flavour of the buttercream? Thanks!
Hi Dara! I’ve never tried this recipe with margarine before, so I can’t say for sure how it will turn out. My hunch is that the consistency will be fine, but it might be more yellow in color and will have a margarine flavor, but as long as you don’t mind the flavor of margarine I’d say give it a try!
Hi Whitney, thanks for your tips!! Buttercream is always too sweet for me. Is there any other ways to make it stiffer without making it sweeter?
Hi Jodie! I hate having buttercream that’s too sweet, which is why my recipe includes less powdered sugar than normal and the addition of salt. If the stiffened version of this recipe is still too sweet for your liking, try adding an extra pinch or two of salt to even out the flavor.
Hi, Am from Peru, and am new in the world of pastry. I followed you for a while, but i didn´t know you have a blog. I love your work, and found this tips it´s awesome. Thanks for sharing all your secrets.
My question is, when you said less powdered sugar and the addition of salt, you meant like change quantities? And if i use less powdered sugar, my buttercream will be thin? I used 334gr of margarine and 167gr of shortening, and 1kg of powder sugar. And i have same problem, flavor its to sweet. I use a peruvian escense called: Leche condensada, not Vanilla. Thanks again for your tips, and by just reading my comment am happy! Best of wishes always!
Hi Johanna! Thanks so much for the kind words! Depending on the consistency of the buttercream (if you want it thicker for piping things like buttercream flowers or thinner for frosting a cake) I recommend using different amounts of powdered sugar, as specified in the Consistency section of this post after the recipe. If your buttercream is too sweet, you can add a little extra salt to tone it down. I always just taste as I go. Hope that helps!
To help cut the sweetness, add some lemon extract to the recipe. Start with 1 teaspoon per 1 kg of powdered sugar. Let it sit for a few minutes, then taste it. You can add another 1/2 teaspoon if you would like. But be careful as adding to much it will change the flavor to a strong lemon flavor.
I don’t even bake and I love watching your posts.
Thank you, Elaine!
Thank you very much!! Love from Holland.
Thanks, Kim! Love from Portland as well!!
If I want to make a Nutella butter cream would I just add Nutella to this recipe also if I wanted to put a filling in my cake could I just put melted Nutella in the middle? Sorry I’m still learning about cakes
Hi Summer! I have a recipe for Nutella buttercream I’d recommend here: https://sugarandsparrow.com/nutella-buttercream-recipe/ and if you’re using Nutella as a filling, be sure to use the “soft fillings method” in this post to fill/stack the cake: https://sugarandsparrow.com/fill-and-stack-cake-layers/ Nutella on it’s own (either melted or piped in between layers as-is) is too thin to use as a filling without first piping the buttercream dam as explained in that blog post. Hope that helps!
Hi, reading your blog and watching your videos has been so helpful for me! if i am layering 3 layers of sponge then icing to a semi naked style how much would you say id need to make of this butter cream? thank you
amber
Hi Amber! For 3 6-inch layers you’ll only need one batch for a semi-naked finish. If your layers are larger in diameter you may need 1.5 batches. Here’s a handy chart I made for calculating buttercream amounts: https://sugarandsparrow.com/how-much-buttercream-do-i-need/
Hallo, wat is dit ‘whole milk or heavy whipping cream’???
Alvast bedankt
Hi Aygul! Whole milk has the highest butterfat percentage of any dairy milk (as opposed to “2%” or “skim milk”, etc) and heavy whipping cream is basically whole milk with an even higher butterfat percentage. What kind of milk do you have over there? I can offer a recommendation if you don’t have access to whole milk or heavy whipping cream.
Hi Whitney,
while I do have whole milk and heavy whipping cream I’m curious to hear your other recommendation. I don’t generally have either at home as we don’t drink milk and the heavy cream always goes to waste after the couple tbsps I use out of the cartons :/
Thanks!
Hi Maria! This recipe is best with either whole milk or heavy whipping cream. I’ve never tried it with any other liquid, but I suppose you could substitute it with any liquid dairy you have on hand. Let me know if you try it with something as a substitute!
I don’t have access to either and have 2% milk at home. What’s your recommendation?
Hi Takwa, you can use 2% milk and the results should be totally fine! Just make sure the milk is room temperature before adding it to the buttercream. I only recommend Whole Milk or Heavy Whipping Cream because that’s usually what I have on hand and the added fat content produces buttercream that’s a little bit fluffier.
I don’t have easy access to whole milk or heavy cream! I’d love a recommendation!
Hi Takwa. Just like I mentioned above, you can use any kind of milk you want. You mentioned having 2% milk at home and that would be totally fine.
Hi Whitney
If I am doing a 3 layer 20cm round cake with a 2 layer 10cm round cake how many quantities do you recommend for layers, crumb coat and frosting?
Thank you
Hi Leanne! To fill, crumb coat, and frost both cakes of those sizes, I would make 2.5 batches of this recipe.
Hi! I don’t have a stand mixer currently. Can I whip this by hand?
Hi Clarissa! This recipe works great with an electronic hand mixer, but if you are planning on trying to whip it up without an electronic device you won’t be able to get the butter whipped enough unfortunately.
Love this recipe. I use it all the time. I have tried lots of different recipes for vanilla buttercream with different ratios but this is the best I have found and the most like the vanilla buttercream I loved as a kid! Thank you!
That’s amazing, Jen! I’m so happy this recipe is nostalgic for you 🙂
Hi Whitney, once I have done the crumbed coating & refrigerate the cake..do I also refrigerate the buttercream?
Hi Colleen! If you’re only refrigerating the crumb coated cake for 20-30 minutes, I would just keep the remaining buttercream at room temperature covered with a cloth. That way it’s ready to go when you move on to frosting the cake. If you’re refrigerating the crumb coated cake overnight, I would refrigerate the buttercream as well and then bring it back to room temp the next day and rewhip it with your stand mixer to bring it back to frosting consistency before frosting the cake. Hope that helps!
My buttercream came out too thin I think, it was dripping down the side of the cake. Did I perhaps let the butter sit out at room temperature for too long?
Hi Jay! The buttercream should never drip down the side of the cake. It sounds like either your butter was too melty to begin with or your kitchen environment was too warm (or both). Here’s a blog post I wrote about how to fix buttercream consistency if you find this happens again: https://sugarandsparrow.com/buttercream-consistency/
Thank you! Love the article. ❤️